My independent (non-scientific) battery test & review ScanShack is a registered trade mark

Testing batteries in the Icom IC-R10


After viewing the numerous TV commercials for the numerous batteries in today's market I wondered.... how long would each of those batteries last in a continuous scanning/receiving mode ?

So I decided to check them out.

* The following tests were done using my Icom IC-R10 general coverage receiver/scanner.

 

The tests consisted of: 

For the record:  The environment for each test could not be completely duplicated with regards to the amount of radio traffic that was being received.  With each set of batteries it was possible that different amounts of duty cycle (receiver/audio circuit active, scanning mode active, etc) were present.  The batteries may have been under different load conditions depending on the amount of traffic. Activity on the police and fire frequencies being monitored vary dependant on community activity but due to the number of different areas programmed into the receiver the amount of traffic was pretty much at a constant and equal level through the day and night for all tests.  This was as fair as I could get as I have no control over the radio traffic.  This would be the equivalent of normal scanning activity being done by a typical scanning hobbyist.

I also contacted (via e-mail or telephone) each of the battery companies to inquire if they desired to have any of their input/comments recorded in this review.  Those that got back to me, Duracell-via e-mail and telephone, Eveready-via e-mail, Kodak via e-mail and they sent me samples and nice brochures. Rayovac never responded to my e-mail.  I have placed all their URLs in each section where material concerning their products can be found.

 

The products tested

Eveready Energizer Advanced Formula AA Alkaline

Price I paid: $3.39

4 Pack

Best if used by date: Jan 2003

Energizer e2 AA Alkaline

 

Price I paid: $4.49

4 Pack

Use by date: 2007

Duracell AA

Alkaline

 

Price I paid: $3.39

4 Pack

Best if installed by date: 2004

Duracell Ultra AA Alkaline

 

Price I paid: $4.19

4 Pack

Guaranteed fresh through: 2006

Test: Tues, 28 Dec 99

Duration until LOW Battery indicator: 11hr 45min

Duration until audio unintelligible: 14hr 30min

http://www.energizer.com/

Test: Fri, 11 Aug 00

Duration until LOW Battery indicator: 12hr 59min

Duration until audio unintelligible: 16hr 39min

http://www.energizer.com/

Test: Wed, 29 Dec 99

Duration until LOW Battery indicator: 12hr 1min

Duration until audio unintelligible: 14hr 40min

http://www.duracell.com/

Test: Thurs, 30 Dec 99

Duration until LOW Battery indicator: 12hr 58min

Duration until audio unintelligible: 16hr 10min

http://www.duracell.com/

Rayovac Maximum AA Alkaline

 

Price I paid: $2.79

4 Pack

Best if used by date: Dec 2004

Rayovac Renewal Rechargeable AA Alkaline

 

Price I paid: $6.99

4 Pack, Charger was $9.99 - 3.00 coupon ($6.99)

 

Kodak PHOTOLIFE AA Alkaline

 

Price I paid: $0, Kodak kindly sent me 24 samples

 

GE/Sanyo AA Alkaline

 

Price I paid: $1.99 4 Pack

Best if used by date: Jan 2004

Test: Fri, 31 Dec 99

Duration until LOW Battery indicator: 10hr 45min

Duration until audio unintelligible: 14hr 13min

http://www.rayovac.com/

Test: Fri, 18 Aug 00 (After full charge)

Duration until LOW Battery indicator: 6hr 22min

Duration until audio unintelligible: 7hr 51min (This test duration was on one charge, Rayovac says you can recharge these 100 times)

http://www.rayovac.com/

Test: Fri, 25 Aug 00

Duration until LOW Battery indicator: 11hr 24min

Duration until audio unintelligible: 14hr 54min

http://www.kodak.com/go/batteries

 

Test: Sat, 2 Sep 00

Duration until LOW Battery indicator: 10hr 53min

Duration until audio unintelligible: 14hr 14min

http://www.sanyo.com/

http://www.ge.com/

                                                 6 Hr                8 Hr                10 Hr            12 Hr            14 Hr          16 Hr

Energizer AA Alkaline


Energizer e2 AA Alkaline


Duracell AA Alkaline


Duracell Ultra AA Alkaline


Rayovac AA Alkaline


Rayovac Rechargeable AA Alkaline (This test duration was on one charge, Rayovac says you can recharge these 100 times)


Kodak PHOTOLIFE AA Alkaline


GE/Sanyo AA Alkaline


 

Type battery
What type batteries do you use in your scanner ?

Rechargeable Nickel-Cadmium (Ni-Cd)
Rechargeable Nickel-Metal Hydride (Ni-MH)
Alkaline
Rechargeable Alkaline
Lithium
Other



Current Results

Thanks !